Tuesday, December 11, 2018

Neville Paradigm: Jaw-dropping paper from 1995 on Henry V

I'm going to start a new series of posts on the "Neville Paradigm". To fully understand, please read my essay on Kuhn's paradigms about applying lessons from his masterful book The Structure of Scientific Revolutions.

The main point is that lots of outstanding Shakespeare scholarship has been done based on the "William Shakespeare" paradigm. Re-evaluating that scholarship under the "Henry Neville" paradigm produces a much deeper understanding of that very scholarship.

I have found an astounding example of this in this paper from 1995:

Womersley, David. “France in Shakespeare's ‘Henry V.’” Renaissance Studies, vol. 9, no. 4, 1995, pp. 442–459. http://www.jstor.org/stable/24412297.
If we consider Henry V in the light of these general considerations, we can see that Shakespeare's depiction of the French is both complex and unusual. Shakespeare combined respect, and even compassion, for the French, with moments of scorn which were both more offensive, and aimed with greater precision, than anything in a precursor such as The Famous Victories of Henry V. Investigation of the high-political rumours current during the play's moment - the summer of 1599 - allows us to explain this distinctive enfolding of aggression within appeasement by reference to the likely interests of the Essexian faction the play seems designed to serve.
Just read that paragraph and compare it with a profile of Sir Henry Neville. Read the whole paper and realize that the detailed knowledge Neville had, and was reflected in the play, was not actually current among everyone in London. It just appears that way because we now have access to people's private letters and government documents.

As ambassador to France, Henry Neville had privileged access to the latest information on every issue discussed in this article.

But more astounding is how Womersley's analysis lines up with Neville's political leanings. Aligned with the "Essexian faction"! What could possibly be MORE spot on? The discussion in the paper on the niceties of the "Salic Law" and its emphasis in the play... Just amazing. And he brings Richard III into the discussion... The most Nevillian of all Neville plays for a dozen different aspects.

Lots more to digest in this paper, but that's enough to make the point.

And this answers the question, of course, of why Neville wanted to publish anonymously. This way, he could express political opinions to a wide audience without attaching his name to it. Shakespeare gave him cover to express his views openly in a way he couldn't by writing plays as "anonymous".


Neville Family Legend? Oak Walk of Billingbear

A possible Neville family legend that Henry Neville wrote the works of Shakespeare is a very important research direction. This discovery may be one piece of that puzzle.

I have found two poems from the 18th and early 19th centuries describing the "Oak-Walk at Billingbear." Sir Henry Neville grew up in Billingbear in Berkshire and returned there after his father's death in 1593.

The first poem is from the 1745, A collection of original poems and translations, by John Whaley, M. A., Fellow of King's-College, Cambridge:


The second poem is even more interesting, published in 1805, Edward Coxe, Esq. Miscellaneous Poetry,

The poem is titled "Inscriptions for the Grotto, At the end of the Oak Walk, at Billingbear."

Here are some excerpts, it begins from the perspective of outside of the walk looking in:

Nor Parian stone, nor costly shell,
Adorns this humble moss-grown cell;
This lowly roof should ne'er supply
A thought that tends to luxury.

But if a rustic plain retreat,
Fit shelter for a hermit's feet,
Can tempt thee from the open glad,
To rest beneath the tranquil shade;

Then inside:

Embow'ring oaks, a stately row,
Around their spreading branches throw,
And tow'ring with gigantic size,
Life their proud summits to the skies.

On either side a verdant lawn,
Glitters with dew-drops in the dawn;
In playful herds the speckled deer
Crop the sweet turf, and wanton here.

Then fancy sees, or seems to see,
Beneath each venerable tree,
Dryads and Hamadryads rove,
Along their consecrated grove:

And as they tread the sacred ground,
Aerial music breathes around,
And choral streams, distinctly clear,
Thus break upon the ravish'd ear: --

For here the Nevilles and the Greys
Protection to the wood-nymph raise;
who hail the best auspicious hour,
When first they chose this sacred bow'r.

And though ye can recall no more
Your Druid Bards' prophetic lore,
Ye still the Poet shall inspire,
And harmonize the British Lyre!

I've bolded the most interesting bits. To me it seems like the author is consciously connecting these woods to Shakespeare's plays. Even if he's not, there are obvious parallels here. The reference to "Druid Bard" very well could directly reference Shakespeare; "Bard of Avon" was already common in the 18th century.

These are the woods of Henry Neville's youth and adulthood. If he did indeed write the plays and poems of William Shakespeare, they almost certainly inspired him.

The more interesting question is whether this poem offers evidence of a family legend about Henry Neville writing the works of Shakespeare. The book is dedicated to Lord Braybrooke:

"As my first attempts at poetical composition were encouraged by Mr. Neville, your late excellent Father, and as several of the earliest pieces in this Miscellany were weritten at Billingbear, where I passed in your society so many of the happiest hours of my life"

The Mr. Neville here refers to Richard Aldworth Neville. I have uncovered some evidence that Richard Aldworth Neville may have known a family legend about his great-great-great-great-grandfather Henry Neville writing the works of Shakespeare. This could possibly be another piece of evidence in that direction.

I could pull up many examples of this poem referencing Shakespeare, but here are a few choice ones that show how someone who grew up at Billingbear might have used the Oak Walk as inspiration and how that might have inspired this poet in the late 18th century: 

 As You Like It, 4.3:

Within an hour; and, pacing through the forest, 
Chewing the food of sweet and bitter fancy, 
Lo, what befell! He threw his eye aside, 
And mark what object did present itself. 
Under an oak, whose boughs were moss'd with age, 
And high top bald with dry antiquity, 
A wretched ragged man, o'ergrown with hair, 

And this from As You Like It, 2.1, the famous deer hunting scene:

To-day my Lord of Amiens and myself 
Did steal behind him as he lay along 
Under an oak whose antique root peeps out 
Upon the brook that brawls along this wood! 
To the which place a poor sequest'red stag, 
That from the hunter's aim had ta'en a hurt, 
Did come to languish; and, indeed, my lord, 
The wretched animal heav'd forth such groans 
That their discharge did stretch his leathern coat 
Almost to bursting; and the big round tears 
Cours'd one another down his innocent nose 
In piteous chase; and thus the hairy fool, 
Much marked of the melancholy Jaques, 
Stood on th' extremest verge of the swift brook, 
Augmenting it with tears.

Remember, deer hunting was a central part of Henry Neville's life from the time he was a child. Note his letter from 1608, published first on this blog, transcribed by our anonymous benefactor:

My hope was to have killed our deere in time to have re
turned to you to dinner, But when I saw he had car[-]
ryed us out as farre as Cramborne, and that yt was
not possible for me to com back in time, I thought
yt as good to stay out his death

And this famous passage from Merry Wives of Windsor, 5.5::

About, about;
Search Windsor Castle, elves, within and out:
Strew good luck, ouphes, on every sacred room:. That it may stand till the perpetual doom,
In state as wholesome as in state 'tis fit,
Worthy the owner, and the owner it.
The several chairs of order look you scour
With juice of balm and every precious flower:
Each fair instalment, coat, and several crest,
With loyal blazon, evermore be blest!
And nightly, meadow-fairies, look you sing, 
Like to the Garter's compass, in a ring:
The expressure that it bears, green let it be,
More fertile-fresh than all the field to see;
And 'Honi soit qui mal y pense' write
In emerald tufts, flowers purple, blue and white;
Let sapphire, pearl and rich embroidery,
Buckled below fair knighthood's bending knee:
Fairies use flowers for their charactery.
Away; disperse: but till 'tis one o'clock,
Our dance of custom round about the oak 
Of Herne the hunter, let us not forget.


Monday, December 10, 2018

Cannons in the Canon 5: Iron Ordnance in King John

The anachronism of cannons in King John has been pointed out for centuries. What's really remarkable is the specificity of the anachronism. In Hamlet, there is talk of "brazen [brass] cannon" because, even though those are probably anachronistic too, at least brass cannons predate iron cannons.

But in King John it's full on "iron indignation". Cannons are even referred to as "ordnance," the technical term current in Elizabethan times. Here is a letter from Henry Neville in 1599:

This King, whatsoever his Meaning is, hath been very careful of late to furnish himself of Ordinance, and hath taken order for the casting of 50 or 60 Pieces here in the Arsenal, whereof 30 are already cast and tried. (WW, 1.130)

Of course, from the mid 1580s to the mid 1590s Henry Neville owned and operated an ironworks in Sussex that produced ordinance. The Oxford Shakespeare estimates the play was written around 1596. Specifically, at the Berkshire Records Office are these documents from 1593-1597. :

"Correspondence, etc., concerning Sir Henry Neville's transactions in the sale and shipment of 'brocken peces' of ordnance"

So we have Neville specifically using the word "ordnance" to refer to cannons in the 1593-1597 period as well as 1599 and 1600. That's some very specific dating.

But Shakespeare actually used "ordnance" from the beginning, several times in fact. Neville owned the ironworks from the mid 1580s so that makes perfect sense. For instance:

Taming of the Shrew, 1.2:
Have I not heard great ordnance in the field,
And heaven's artillery thunder in the skies?

Henry VI, Part 1:
A piece of ordnance 'gainst it I have placed;
And even these three days have I watch'd,
If I could see them.

Interestingly, George Peele uses "ordnance" in the same time period. Raises some interesting questions.

But please focus here on "iron indignation":

Act II, Scene 1:
KING JOHN
For our advantage; therefore hear us first.
These flags of France, that are advanced here
Before the eye and prospect of your town,
Have hither march'd to your endamagement:
The cannons have their bowels full of wrath,
And ready mounted are they to spit forth
Their iron indignation 'gainst your walls:
All preparation for a bloody siege
All merciless proceeding by these French
Confronts your city's eyes, your winking gates;
And but for our approach those sleeping stones,
That as a waist doth girdle you about,
By the compulsion of their ordinance
By this time from their fixed beds of lime
Had been dishabited, and wide havoc made
For bloody power to rush upon your peace.
But on the sight of us your lawful king,
Who painfully with much expedient march
Have brought a countercheque before your gates,
To save unscratch'd your city's threatened cheeks,
Behold, the French amazed vouchsafe a parle;
And now, instead of bullets wrapp'd in fire,
To make a shaking fever in your walls,
They shoot but calm words folded up in smoke,
To make a faithless error in your ears:
Which trust accordingly, kind citizens,
And let us in, your king, whose labour'd spirits,
Forwearied in this action of swift speed,
Crave harbourage within your city walls.
KING PHILIP
When I have said, make answer to us both.
Lo, in this right hand, whose protection
Is most divinely vow'd upon the right
Of him it holds, stands young Plantagenet,
Son to the elder brother of this man,
And king o'er him and all that he enjoys:
For this down-trodden equity, we tread
In warlike march these greens before your town,
Being no further enemy to you
Than the constraint of hospitable zeal
In the relief of this oppressed child
Religiously provokes. Be pleased then
To pay that duty which you truly owe
To that owes it, namely this young prince:
And then our arms, like to a muzzled bear,
Save in aspect, hath all offence seal'd up;
Our cannons' malice vainly shall be spent
Against the invulnerable clouds of heaven;
And with a blessed and unvex'd retire,
With unhack'd swords and helmets all unbruised,
We will bear home that lusty blood again
Which here we came to spout against your town,
And leave your children, wives and you in peace.
But if you fondly pass our proffer'd offer,
'Tis not the roundure of your old-faced walls
Can hide you from our messengers of war,
Though all these English and their discipline
Were harbour'd in their rude circumference.
Then tell us, shall your city call us lord,
In that behalf which we have challenged it?
Or shall we give the signal to our rage
And stalk in blood to our possession?

Saturday, December 8, 2018

They know not what they say: Hamlet and the vile phrase beautified

Saw this in Wikipedia, too funny:
Greenblatt has also suggested that a line in Hamlet is a dig at Greene's phrase in Groatsworth, "beautified with our feathers". Polonius, reading a letter from Hamlet addressed to "the most beautified Ophelia", comments disparagingly that "beautified is a vile phrase".
The full quote from Hamlet, 2.2  is even better pun on "ne vile velis" and "Nevill" (how Neville spelled his own name). If Greenblatt is right that the author is referencing Greene's Groats-Worth of Wit, then this is DEFINITELY a Neville-name-motto pun:
That's an ill phrase, a vile phrase; 'beautified' is a vile phrase.
However, Greenblatt is probably just finding a coincidence here. But who knows. With a connection that tenuous, you can prove anything...

Here's Two Gentlemen of Verona, 4.1:
And partly, seeing you are beautifiedWith goodly shape and by your own report
A linguist and a man of such perfection
As we do in our quality much want

More on Deer and Merry Wives of Windsor

Compare Neville's letter from 1606:

I am very sorry that it lies not in my power to send you a half a buck; my keepers tell me that there is none in my walk; sure I am that have not seene a pasty of venison of this yeere. I did adventure to send you the side of a stag which I thought might serve your turne as well if it came sweet to you, which the heate of the weather made me fearfull of.

To this from Merry Wives of Windsor, 5.5:

FALSTAFF. Divide me like a bribe buck, each a haunch: I will keep my sides to myself, my shoulders for the fellow of this walk, and my horns I bequeath your husbands. Am I a woodman, ha? Speak I like Herne the hunter? Why, now is Cupid a child of conscience; he makes restitution. As I am a true spirit, welcome!

Friday, December 7, 2018

New Transcription of Henry Neville Letter! - 15 Sept 1608

If you're a Henry Neville aficionado, you've seen this in the Calendar of State Papers Domestic Series, 1603-1610, Page 456 for 1608:


Such a tantalizing but brief summary! Well, an anonymous benefactor has transcribed this letter for the greater good of the Neville research community:

S[i]r, I am much ashamed of the errors which were redoubled
towards you yesterday. First by my self in forsaking you
And next by my people, in their yll attending you.
My hope was to have killed our deere in time to have re
turned to you to dinner, But when I saw he had car[-]
ryed us out as farre as Cramborne, and that yt was
not possible for me to com back in time, I thought
yt as good to stay out his death, presuming of their
discrecion at home, not to have stayed your dinner
for me. But I perceave errors yo[u] not single but
one commontly begets another, as bad, if not worse
then my self. I pray you pardon both; ?Con[-]
fession and contrition you have already, which are two
parts of penance. The third, satisfaction, sall be
when ?a ?hon, you will ?Injorne yt. And so hoping,
and desyring to heere, that your comming abroade
yesterday, did you no other harme, but the losse of
your dinner, I commend me hartyly unto you, and
rest

Evermore at your commande
Henry Nevill

We can draw lots of connections between this and Shakespeare's works, but I think I like this one best, compare to bold sentence above:

He eats nothing but doves, love, and that breeds hot 
blood, and hot blood begets hot thoughts, and hot 
thoughts beget hot deeds, and hot deeds is love. Troilus and Cressida, 3.1

Here is the source image. I strongly feel that if the Neville community can work together to share research materials and findings, definitive proof will be discovered in short order.

Update 1/26/2019: John O'Donnell offers a different reading of some of these lines:  A couple of corrections to the transcription of Neville's letter: …But I perceave errors go not single but one commonly begets another, as bad, yf not worse then yt self…The third, satisfaction, shall be when & how, you will Injoine yt…


Monday, December 3, 2018

What were Henry Neville's Visiting Hours in Prison?

Interesting note on who was allowed to visit Henry Neville when he was in prison: